Comparison of Digital Breast Tomosynthesis and Mammography-based Radiomics for Breast Cancer Risk Assessment: Case-Control Study

Radiology Imaging Cancer · 2025-07-01

Three-dimensional radiomic analysis of digital breast tomosynthesis outperformed two-dimensional measures in breast cancer risk assessment.

AAPM task group 234 report: Virtual tools for the evaluation of new 3D/4D breast imaging systems

Medical Physics · 2025-12-25

Abstract Simulation methods in breast imaging offer advantages over clinical trials in terms of improved reproducibility, reduced need for patient exposure to radiation, increased flexibility, and more clearly defined ground truth. Simulation also allows for improved representation of anatomical variations and variations in acquisition parameters and breast positioning related to multimodality imaging. The increasing use of virtual clinical trials (VCTs) to assess breast imaging systems has introduced a demand to optimize protocols for simulation studies. This work will contribute to developing standards for evaluation tools for 3D/4D breast imaging systems and will ultimately reduce the reliance on clinical trials for emerging systems. This report reviews key aspects of VCTs, including the simulation of realistic breast anatomy, the generation of synthetic images from virtual phantoms, the use of model observers to assess imaging system performance, and methods to analyze observer outputs. Each section reviews the state of the science and recommends approaches for accomplishing tasks related to the individual aspects of VCTs. The report also reviews the experience of designing and using a simulation approach from the industrial and regulatory perspective. Finally, future steps in the development of VCTs are suggested. breast cancer imaging, evaluation of imaging systems, virtual trials

Line‐based iterative geometric calibration method for a tomosynthesis system

Medical Physics · 2024-02-23 · 1 citations

BACKGROUND: A next generation tomosynthesis (NGT) system, capable of two-dimensional source motion, detector motion in the perpendicular direction, and magnification tomosynthesis, was constructed to investigate different acquisition geometries. Existing position-based geometric calibration methods proved ineffective when applied to the NGT geometries. PURPOSE: A line-based iterative calibration method is developed to perform accurate geometric calibration for the NGT system. METHODS: The proposed method calculates the system geometry through virtual line segments created by pairs of fiducials within a calibration phantom, by minimizing the error between the line equations computed from the true and estimated fiducial projection pairs. It further attempts to correct the 3D fiducial locations based on the initial geometric calibration. The method's performance was assessed via simulation and experimental setups with four distinct NGT geometries: X, T, XZ, and TZ. The X geometry resembles a conventional DBT acquisition along the chest wall. The T geometry forms a "T"-shaped source path in mediolateral (ML) and posteroanterior (PA) directions. A descending detector motion is added to both X and T geometries to form the XZ and TZ geometries, respectively. Simulation studies were conducted to assess the robustness of the method to geometric perturbations and inaccuracies in fiducial locations. Experimental studies were performed to assess the impact of phantom magnification and the performance of the proposed method for various geometries, compared to the traditional position-based method. Star patterns were evaluated for both qualitative and quantitative analyses; the Fourier spectral distortions (FSDs) graphs and the contrast transfer function (CTF) were extracted. The limit of spatial resolution (LSR) was measured at 5% modulation of the CTF. RESULTS: The proposed method presented is highly robust to geometric perturbation and fiducial inaccuracies. After the line-based iterative method, the mean distance between the true and estimated fiducial projections was [X, T, XZ, TZ]: [0.01, 0.01, 0.02, 0.01] mm. The impact of phantom magnification was observed; a contact-mode acquisition of a calibration phantom successfully provided an accurate geometry for 1.85× magnification images of a star pattern, with the X geometry. The FSD graphs for the contact-mode T geometry acquisition presented evidence of super-resolution, with the LSR of [0°-quadrant: 8.57, 90°-quadrant: 8.47] lp/mm. Finally, a contact-mode XZ geometry acquisition and a 1.50× magnification TZ geometry acquisition were reconstructed with three calibration methods-position-based, line-based, and iterative line-based. As more advanced methods are applied, the CTF becomes more isotropic, the FSD graphs demonstrate less spectral leakage as super-resolution is achieved, and the degree of blurring artifacts reduces significantly. CONCLUSIONS: This study introduces a robust calibration method tailored to the unique requirements of advanced tomosynthesis systems. By employing virtual line segments and iterative techniques, we ensure accurate geometric calibration while mitigating the limitations posed by the complex acquisition geometries of the NGT system. Our method's ability to handle various NGT configurations and its tolerance to fiducial misalignment make it a superior choice compared to traditional calibration techniques.

Exploring advanced 2D acquisitions in breast tomosynthesis: T-shaped and pentagon geometries

2024-05-29

In this study, we investigate the performance of advanced 2D acquisition geometries - Pentagon and T-shaped - in digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) and compare them against the conventional 1D geometry. Unlike the conventional approach, our proposed 2D geometries also incorporate anterior projections away from the chest wall. Implemented on the Next-Generation Tomosynthesis (NGT) prototype developed by X-ray Physics Lab (XPL), UPenn, we utilized various phantoms to compare three geometries: a Defrise slab phantom with alternating plastic slabs to study low-frequency modulation; a Checkerboard breast phantom (a 2D adaptation of the Defrise phantom design) to study the ability to reconstruct the fine features of the checkerboard squares; and the 360° Star-pattern phantom to assess aliasing and compute the Fourier-spectral distortion (FSD) metric that assesses spectral leakage and the contrast transfer function. We find that both Pentagon and T-shaped scans provide greater modulation amplitude of the Defrise phantom slabs and better resolve the squares of the Checkerboard phantom against the conventional scan. Notably, the Pentagon geometry exhibited a significant reduction in aliasing of spatial frequencies oriented in the right-left (RL) medio-lateral direction, which was corroborated by a near complete elimination of spectral leakage in the FSD plot. Conversely T-shaped scan redistributes the aliasing between both posteroanterior (PA) and RL directions thus maintaining non-inferiority against the conventional scan which is predominantly affected by PA aliasing. The results of this study underscore the potential of incorporating advanced 2D geometries in DBT systems, offering marked improvements in imaging performance over the conventional 1D approach.

Impact of super-resolution and image acquisition on the detection of calcifications in digital breast tomosynthesis

European Radiology · 2023-08-12 · 8 citations

Abstract P070: Volumetric parenchymal pattern analysis for breast cancer risk estimation

Cancer Prevention Research · 2023-01-01

Abstract Introduction: Mammographic breast density is among the strongest risk factors for breast cancer. However, breast density is typically assessed subjectively by the radiologist according to the Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System (BI-RADS) based on 2 dimensional (2D) digital mammography (DM) images. Digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) is quickly replacing DM and allows more detailed volumetric imaging of the breast. Advances in radiomics, the high-throughput extraction of radiologic features, has enabled characterization of breast parenchymal complexity beyond breast density alone. The purpose of this study was to compare the performance of volumetric parenchymal pattern analysis from DBT and DM with conventional breast density measurement with respect to breast cancer risk estimation. Methods: We performed a case control study among women with concurrent DM and DBT screening (Selenia Dimensions, Hologic Inc.) at our institution between 3/2011-12/2014. Cases were diagnosed with breast cancer within 1 year of screening; controls were confirmed negative or benign at 1 year follow-up, matched on race (Black, White, other/unknown) and age (5-year bins). After exclusions for imaging artifacts, craniocaudal (CC) and mediolateral oblique (MLO) views for 187 cases and 737 controls, in six image formats were assessed: 1) raw (“FOR PROCESSING”) DM; 2) processed (“FOR PRESENTATION”) DM; 3) raw DBT central projection; 4) processed DBT central projection; 5) DBT central reconstructed slice; and 6) DBT reconstructed stack. For cases, we analyzed the breast contralateral to cancer diagnosis; for controls the same breast as the matched case. We extracted radiomic features using a lattice-based approach with the publicly available CaPTk software, averaging features for each breast over CC and MLO views. We examined 3 lattice window sizes (6.4, 12.8, and 25.6 mm) and 23 resolutions for image resampling (0.075 - 2mm). We performed PCA on the resulting 487 features for each combination of window size and resolution and built conditional logistic regression models to assess the association of the first 7 principal components with breast cancer, with models including age, BMI, and BI-RADS density. For each image type we calculated the model C-statistic at all window sizes and resolutions, for a total of 2304 experimental conditions. Results: Features from reconstructed DBT scans had on average higher C-statistics across all experimental conditions. A model using only age, BMI, and BI-RADS density had a C-statistic of 0.61. Models using radiomic features plus age, BMI, and BI-RADS density had mean C-statistic of 0.68 (IQR 0.68, 0.69) for reconstructed DBT scans; for all other image types, the mean C-statistic ranged from 0.64 to 0.66. Conclusions: Incorporating volumetric breast parenchymal patterns from DBT improves breast cancer risk estimation beyond markers derived from DM and beyond conventional BI-RADS density. Citation Format: Eric A. Cohen, Omid Haji Maghsoudi, Raymond Acciavatti, Lauren Pantalone, Walter Mankowski, Alex A Nguyen, Christopher G. Scott, Stacey Winham, Andrew D. Maidment, Anne Marie McCarthy, Celine M Vachon, Emily F Conant, Despina Kontos. Volumetric parenchymal pattern analysis for breast cancer risk estimation. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference: Precision Prevention, Early Detection, and Interception of Cancer; 2022 Nov 17-19; Austin, TX. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Can Prev Res 2023;16(1 Suppl): Abstract nr P070.

Multiclass Segmentation of Breast Tissue and Suspicious Findings: A Simulation-Based Study for the Development of Self-Steering Tomosynthesis

Tomography · 2023-06-10

In breast tomosynthesis, multiple low-dose projections are acquired in a single scanning direction over a limited angular range to produce cross-sectional planes through the breast for three-dimensional imaging interpretation. We built a next-generation tomosynthesis system capable of multidirectional source motion with the intent to customize scanning motions around "suspicious findings". Customized acquisitions can improve the image quality in areas that require increased scrutiny, such as breast cancers, architectural distortions, and dense clusters. In this paper, virtual clinical trial techniques were used to analyze whether a finding or area at high risk of masking cancers can be detected in a single low-dose projection and thus be used for motion planning. This represents a step towards customizing the subsequent low-dose projection acquisitions autonomously, guided by the first low-dose projection; we call this technique "self-steering tomosynthesis." A U-Net was used to classify the low-dose projections into "risk classes" in simulated breasts with soft-tissue lesions; class probabilities were modified using post hoc Dirichlet calibration (DC). DC improved the multiclass segmentation (Dice = 0.43 vs. 0.28 before DC) and significantly reduced false positives (FPs) from the class of the highest risk of masking (sensitivity = 81.3% at 2 FPs per image vs. 76.0%). This simulation-based study demonstrated the feasibility of identifying suspicious areas using a single low-dose projection for self-steering tomosynthesis.

Spatial dependency of multiplanar reconstruction in digital breast tomosynthesis

2023-04-07 · 1 citations

Tomosynthesis acquires projections over a limited angular range, resulting in anisotropic sampling in the Fourier domain. The volume of the sampled space is therefore spatially dependent; different Fourier components are sampled for the same object, depending upon where the object is located relative to the system origin. A next-generation tomosynthesis (NGT) system was developed at the University of Pennsylvania to increase the spatial isotropy in DBT, by incorporating additional system motions. In this work, we investigate the spatial dependency of image quality in tomosynthesis and compare conventional and NGT tomosynthesis in terms of multiplanar reconstruction (MPR). Two test objects, a high-frequency star pattern and a low-frequency octagon phantom, were placed throughout the detector field of view at various obliquities to analyze the anisotropic nature of tomosynthesis. Reconstructions of the star pattern were analyzed both qualitatively and quantitatively using the Fourier distortion metric (FSD). Reconstructions of the octagon phantom were analyzed qualitatively. In a separate experiment, a container filled with water and acrylic beads of various diameters were imaged at various locations to simulate low-contrast objects mimicking breast tissue. We show that the spatial dependency of MPR is unique to the tilt angle, orientation, and frequency of the input. The NGT geometry benefitted the visualization of objects by reducing the out-of-plane artifacts in MPR.

Non-Isocentric Geometry for Next-Generation Tomosynthesis With Super-Resolution

IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging · 2023-08-21 · 3 citations

Our lab at the University of Pennsylvania (UPenn) is investigating novel designs for digital breast tomosynthesis. We built a next-generation tomosynthesis system with a non-isocentric geometry (superior-to-inferior detector motion). This paper examines four metrics of image quality affected by this design. First, aliasing was analyzed in reconstructions prepared with smaller pixelation than the detector. Aliasing was assessed with a theoretical model of r -factor, a metric calculating amplitudes of alias signal relative to input signal in the Fourier transform of the reconstruction of a sinusoidal object. Aliasing was also assessed experimentally with a bar pattern (illustrating spatial variations in aliasing) and 360°-star pattern (illustrating directional anisotropies in aliasing). Second, the point spread function (PSF) was modeled in the direction perpendicular to the detector to assess out-of-plane blurring. Third, power spectra were analyzed in an anthropomorphic phantom developed by UPenn and manufactured by Computerized Imaging Reference Systems (CIRS), Inc. (Norfolk, VA). Finally, calcifications were analyzed in the CIRS Model 020 BR3D Breast Imaging Phantom in terms of signal-to-noise ratio (SNR); i.e., mean calcification signal relative to background-tissue noise. Image quality was generally superior in the non-isocentric geometry: Aliasing artifacts were suppressed in both theoretical and experimental reconstructions prepared with smaller pixelation than the detector. PSF width was also reduced at most positions. Anatomic noise was reduced. Finally, SNR in calcification detection was improved. (A potential trade-off of smaller-pixel reconstructions was reduced SNR; however, SNR was still improved by the detector-motion acquisition.) In conclusion, the non-isocentric geometry improved image quality in several ways.