Resources

Interview guide

How to prepare for a PhD advisor interview, what to ask, and the traps that hurt even strong applicants.

01

Before the call (48 hours out)

  • Re-read the professor's last two papers top to bottom — not just abstracts. Mark the sections that genuinely surprised you.
  • Check the lab website for who recently graduated and where they went. This tells you more about trajectory than any rankings do.
  • Open the PhdFit meeting-prep sheet — the Meeting Prep Compiler pulls these signals automatically.
  • Write down three questions that only make sense if you read the papers carefully. Those are the ones worth asking.
02

In the first five minutes

  • Lead with a specific thread from their work. "I was struck by your handling of X in the 2024 paper" beats "I'm interested in your research."
  • Be honest about your background. Overstating experience falls apart within 60 seconds of a real technical question.
  • Let the professor drive. They will tell you which project they care about most — that's the project to talk about.
03

The questions to ask

  • "How do you and your students decide what to work on?" — reveals whether the lab is directive or self-driven.
  • "What has surprised you about the research agenda in the last year?" — opens a window into how the professor updates their views.
  • "What do your students who graduate into industry research wish they'd started earlier?" — produces concrete trajectory advice.
  • "Are you admitting students this cycle?" — ask plainly near the end, not between the lines. Polite directness is read as maturity.
04

Traps to avoid

  • Asking questions already answered on the lab website. Trains the professor to see you as under-prepared.
  • Pitching a specific project you want to do. Most PIs want to see how you think, not whether you already have a plan. Save that for after admission.
  • Treating the call as a test. It's mutual. You should leave with a read on whether this lab is somewhere you'd survive three difficult years.
05

After the call

  • Send a thank-you within 24 hours — specific, short, references one thing you discussed.
  • Write yourself a private note: energy, fit, red flags. You will have forgotten the texture of the call in a week.
  • Update the PhdFit shortlist bucket (reach / target / safer / not sure) based on what you learned, not what you hoped.